Posts Tagged ‘land management’

Morning Read: Did the Adirondack Park Agency gloss over Big Tupper wildlife concerns?

February 14th, 2012 by Brian Mann

Last month's decision by state officials to allow construction of the massive Big Tupper resort continues to simmer out there.  A legal challenge could still come, with the deadline for a decision by green groups set for April 1st.

In today's Adirondack Almanack, David Gibson – co-head of the group Adirondack Wild — points to what he views as a glaring shift in how the Adirondack Park Agency treated wildlife concerns on the 6,200 acre property.

Gibson points to this passage, in official documents prepared by the APA in late October 2011.

“A comprehensive biological inventory of the project site was not conducted, so it is not possible to make specific findings concerning impacts to habitat from the proposed project or to identify the presence or location of specific areas on the project site that should be prioritized for protection.”

Gibson argues that just a few months later, the APA was sounding a very different tune.  In official documents prepared in January 2012, that paragraph is deleted and replaced with this:

“Site investigations to evaluate wildlife and wildlife habitat on the project site followed standard Agency guidelines and procedures. In addition to reviewing historical records for threatened and endangered species, qualitative biological surveys including on site visual assessments as defined in Agency guidance ‘Guidelines for Biological Surveys’ were completed during site visits. Other than identifying the deer wintering area as a key wildlife habitat, no other wildlife habitat was identified as containing threatened, endangered or species of special concern on the project site.”

During debate and discussion by the APA commission over the last several months, it became clear that wildlife surveys on the property were rudimentary at best, a fact that prompted a lot of concern even from board members who ultimately voted Yes.

State officials reported that when an independent scientist visited the property, a significant number of new amphibians were identified in a single day.  (The developer's review team failed to identify a single amphibian.)

APA board member Judith Drabicki, who represents the Conservation Department, pointed out during public discussions that DEC guidelines for evaluating endangered species concerns are significantly more rigorous than the methods used by the APA.

This may seem like yesterday's news.  But the issue Gibson raises could inform whether or not green groups sue to challenge the Big Tupper permit.

These questions could also be key to any discussion of reforming the Park Agency's procedures for reviewing big projects in the future.

Morning Read 2: NY Times weighs in with story on Big Tupper resort

February 9th, 2012 by Brian Mann

The New York Times ran a major story on the Adirondack Club and Resort project.  As this is the first report that many influential New Yorkers will see about the development, I thought it was worth noting.

By and large, the story reported by Lisa Foderaro is fairly low-key, taking stock of the conflicts but also acknowledging that the decision was perhaps a bit less controversial that might have been expected.  Here's a sample:

In the early decades of the Adirondack Park Agency, which was formed in 1971, tensions around private-property rights occasionally turned violent.

That pitch of anger has subsided. Now even some environmental groups talk about the importance of development. One such group, the Adirondack Council, endorsed the resort plan in the end.

Check out the full article here.

Do you welcome the return of Bob Glennon?

January 31st, 2012 by Brian Mann

My interview with Bob Glennon a week or so ago was the first time I'd ever spoken more than a word or two to a man who played a pivotal role in modern Adirondack history.

Glennon was an attorney and executive director at the APA during one of its most turbulent eras, a time when conflict was the rule and the tiny state agency's very existence was viewed as an affront by many locals.

He hasn't exactly been absent from the scene in recent years.  He worked for the New York state Attorney General during a time when environmental and Park issues were being litigated fairly regularly.

My first impressions?  A smart, funny guy who likes to mix it up, who seemed to relish — or at least value — the idea of conflict.

Where others in the Park seem ready to bury the hatchet, Glennon made an impassioned argument that "peace in the kingdom" can't be the top priority.

He even chided other environmentalists for partnering recently with "strange bedfellows."  He cited Brian Houseal, head of the Adirondack Council, who has worked to develop the Adirondack Common Ground Alliance with local government leaders.

And he pointed to environmental activist and Adirondack Explorer publisher Dick Beamish, who has partnered with snowmobile activist Jim McCulley in the "rails-to-trails" debate.

Finally, Glennon suggests that the recent Adirondack Club and Resort decision by the APA will spark a revival of a more vibrant, activist green movement in the Park.

So check out our conversation here and then chime in.  Do you think it's time for a return to a more head-to-head debate in the Park?  Do you want more fire and vinegar?

Or do you think the "common ground" era is a good direction for various factions to take?

Green protest planned for Adirondack Park Agency meeting

December 14th, 2011 by Brian Mann

Environmental activists in the North Country are circulating an email trying to arrange a last-minute protest in Ray Brook tomorrow and Friday, as the Adirondack Park Agency meets to review the Big Tupper resort project.

A final decision on the project is expected in January.

The message was initially circulated by activist Richard Brummel December 9th, with an organizational meeting held at Clarkson University in Potsdam last night.

"I am reaching out to activists upstate to put together a last ditch demo or action to bring attention the very imminent approval of a disastrous new resort development in wilderness/woodland areas of the Adirondack Park," Brummel writes.

His message continues as follows:

"Cuomo just stacked the Adirondack Park Agency with pro-development upstate Republican types. After SEVEN YEARS of meandering process the Agency will vote in JANUARY on the little-publicized private "Adirondack Club and Resort" project — a ski-golf-marina resort in a peaceful little small town."

Brummel says one of his goals is to attract interest from downstate media.

Erin Corrigan, head of Clarkson's Ecological Conservation Organization also circulated an email suggesting that the development is planned "in some designated wildereness areas in the Tupper Lake area of the park."

"Without a large amount of resistance the APA will let this wilderness be destroyed. We need as many people as possible to attend these demonstrations. We also need people to bombard the agency with letters and phone calls before they make their decision in January."

Two points of factual clarification:

- If approved by the APA, the proposed development will not be built in a designated wilderness area, but on an area of privately owned land that has been logged for decades.

- Governor Andrew Cuomo recently made two appointments to the APA board, naming one new members to the panel and asking Lani Ulrich to serve as chair.  Both nominations were widely praised by environmental activists in the Park. (The newest APA board member chosen by Cuomo is a member of the Adirondack Mountain Club.)

Morning Read 2: 2,000 acres of Adirondack timberland on the market

November 25th, 2011 by Brian Mann

The Watertown Daily Times is reporting that a company called Lassiter Properties is selling more than 2,000 acres of timberland in the Adirondacks in St. Lawrence County.

If money were not tight, the state would probably want to protect the latest offering, said Michael J. Contino, real property supervisor for the state Department of Environmental Conservation.

“It’s land that would be of interest but there’s really no money available,” he said. “We’ve talked on and off for years with Lassiter about different lands.”

The newspaper notes that Lassiter has been selling its holdings for years, including a deal with New York state that has already blocked future development on more than 55,000 acres of land.

Hat tip:  Adirondack Explorer

Breaking: Vermont bans ATVs on state land

November 23rd, 2011 by Brian Mann

This from the Burlington Free Press:

Vermont is repealing a 2009 rule allowing use of all-terrain vehicles on state land.

Agency of Natural Resources Secretary Deb Markowitz announced the change in a news release today, citing a spring public hearing and the receipt of thousands of comments on the issue.

“I was pleased to see so many Vermonters weigh in on the issue of whether it makes sense for ATVs to ride on public land," Markowitz said in the news release. " After weighing the substance of the comments and concerns about the legality of the original rule we decided to move ahead on the repeal. We have also taken concrete steps to address the Vermont ATV Sportsmen’s Association legitimate need for limited connector trails across public land.”

Read the full article here.

Morning Read: Glennon to "re-enter the Adirondack wars"

November 15th, 2011 by Brian Mann

Bob Glennon is one of the most influential and controversial figures in Adirondack Park history.  He joined the APA in 1974 as associate counsel and rose to serve as executive director before his departure in 1995.

Those were big, turbulent years for the Agency.  After a lengthy stint in the NY Attorney General's office in Plattsburgh, Glennon is retiring at age 66 but says he plans to re-engage Park policy issues.

This from the Adirondack Daily Enterprise.

While he's retired from state service, Glennon said he plans to get involved again in Adirondack Park-related issues. He's currently doing some volunteer legal work for the environmental group Protect the Adirondacks and said he has also met recently with Dan Plumley of Adirondack Wild: Friends of the Forest Preserve.

"I hope to re-enter the Adirondack wars," Glennon told the Enterprise. "I've spent the entire day on Adirondack Forest Preserve issues."

Read the full article here.

For first time, St. Lawrence County sends resident to APA board

November 9th, 2011 by Brian Mann

According to a statement released today by Gov. Cuomo's office, Wanakena resident Sherman Craig will be the first St. Lawrence County resident to serve on the APA commission in its 40-plus year history.

Here's Craig's statement:

“It would be a privilege to serve as a commissioner on the APA Board and I thank Governor Cuomo for this nomination. I am pleased to be able to return to public service in New York, especially a position involving the Adirondack Park where I call home. The Park offers an abundance of unique resources, many of which I use in my business and can be leveraged to develop the local economy. I look forward to working with the Agency to help Governor Cuomo rebuild New York.”

Craig, a former educator and furniture maker, will require confirmation by the state Senate, but his nomination drew praise from state Senator Betty Little and environmental leaders.

"Sherman Craig, filling the vacancy of Curt Stiles, will be St. Lawrence County's first ‘in-park’ commissioner," Sen. Little said.

"It is critical that we have all the park seats filled as this agency moves forward with a new chair and with many important projects to consider. As a small business owner, Sherman brings an important perspective to the board and is another smart choice by Governor Cuomo.”

That view was echoed by Adirondack Mountain Club head Neil Woodworth.  (Craig is a member of ADK.)

"Through his innovative leadership in creating the Cranberry 50 trail and Little River canoe/kayak access projects, Sherman has demonstrated that public use of the Forest Preserve can promote sustainable tourism and economic development for Adirondack communities," Woodworth said.

UPDATE: Gov. Cuomo picks Lani Ulrich to head APA

November 9th, 2011 by Brian Mann

"Lani" Ulrich. NCPR file photo

This release just appeared on Governor Andrew Cuomo's website:

Governor Andrew M. Cuomo announced the appointment of Leilani Crafts Ulrich and the nomination Sherman Craig to positions within the Adirondack Park Agency (APA). Ms. Ulrich will be designated to serve as Chairwoman of the APA and Mr. Craig will be nominated to serve as one of the Commissioners of the APA.

“The Adirondack Park is one of this nation’s greatest natural resources, and I am confident that it will thrive under Lani and Sherman’s leadership,” said Governor Cuomo. “Both Leilani and Sherman have dedicated their lives to the preservation and development of the Park. They recognize the need to balance economic development within the Adirondacks with constant environmental protections. I look forward to working with them to further the development and preservation of this extraordinary park.”

Leilani “Lani” Crafts Ulrich said, “As a resident of Old Forge in the Adirondack Park, I know firsthand the great potential of the Park. Each summer, I have worked with over 100 government agencies, towns and villages across the Park, listening to their concerns and working toward common ground on land-use issues. As Chairwoman, I look forward to using this and other community development experience to develop planning opportunities, as well as to fine-tune the regulatory process in ways that will empower communities and maximize the potential of the Park’s land use while continuing to protect its world class natural resources. I thank Governor Cuomo for this exciting opportunity.”

Sherman Craig said “It would be a privilege to serve as a commissioner on the APA Board and I thank Governor Cuomo for this nomination. I am pleased to be able to return to public service in New York, especially a position involving the Adirondack Park where I call home. The Park offers an abundance of unique resources, many of which I use in my business and can be leveraged to develop the local economy. I look forward to working with the Agency to help Governor Cuomo rebuild New York.”

Leilani Crafts Ulrich was appointed to the APA in November 2004 and then reappointed in 2008. She moved to Old Forge permanently in 1994. In 1997, she began coordination of community discussions which grew into the Central Adirondack Partnership for the 21st Century (CAP-21), a regional non-profit community development organization serving hamlets in Long Lake, inlet, Webb and Forestport on the western side of the Park. CAP-21 strives for balance between nature and commerce by increasing communication to build partnerships amongst diverse groups. The group supported comprehensive master planning, architectural preservation and regional planning efforts. CAP-21 assists small community groups in areas of economic development, social services expansion and recreational development. Ms. Ulrich sits on the Board of Directors of the Central Adirondack Business Association (CAA) and on the Architectural Preservation Committee of the Webb Historical Association. Regionally, she is on the Board of the Adirondack Community Housing Trust and serves as a member of the New York State delegation to the Northern Forest Center’s Sustainable Economies Initiative. For her visioning work with Communities 2000, she received the Adirondack North Country Association (ANCA) Citizen of the Year Award. Past affiliations include the Fulton Chain of Lakes Performing Arts Council, Mountain Theatre, and the Community Chorus of Old Forge. Ms. Ulrich received her B.A. in Liberal Arts Mount Union College in 1978 and her Master Degree in Education Lesley University in 1985. She and her husband reside in Old Forge.

Sherman Craig is a retired teacher and school administrator, currently operating his own business, Wanakena Woodworks, which makes rustic and fine furniture by using local resources within the Adirondack Park. He is an active outdoors traveler and volunteer, and is a current member of several organizations including the Clifton-Fine Economic Corp, Adirondack Mountain Club, and the Waterfront Revitalization Project. He is Chairman of the 5 Ponds Partner subcommittee, managing relationships with groups associated with trail development and maintenance. His committee developed the Cranberry Lake 50 hike and assisted in the opening the Alice Brook snowmobile trail and bridge.

Previously, Mr. Craig held several positions in Pittsford, New York schools including principal, teacher, building administrator and district administrator. During his tenure as principal of a middle school, his building and district won several honors including a National School of Recognition and the New York State Governor’s Excelsior Award for quality and efficiency. From 1973 to 1975, he served as Director and Headmaster of the International School of Belgrade, Yugoslavia. He retired in 1999 as Assistant to the Superintendent for Technology.

Mr. Craig was raised in Rochester, New York and currently resides in Wanakena with his wife, Annette. He holds B.S. and M.S. degrees from SUNY Brockport and a M.A. from University of Rochester.

Senator Betty Little said “I applaud Governor Andrew Cuomo’s selection of Lani Ulrich to lead the Adirondack Park Agency. I’ve known Lani for many years and am fully confident she will provide high-quality leadership for this agency whose decisions impact the lives and livelihoods of many I represent. As a founding member of Adirondack Common Ground, she understands that constructive dialogue between local governments, business and community leaders and environmental advocates will ensure economic needs and environmental stewardship are balanced in the Park. She understands the issues well, she’s a very good listener and has the ability and interest in forging consensus. Sherman Craig, filling the vacancy of Curt Stiles, will be St. Lawrence County's first ‘in-park’ commissioner. It is critical that we have all the park seats filled as this agency moves forward with a new chair and with many important projects to consider. As a small business owner, Sherman brings an important perspective to the board and is another smart choice by Governor Cuomo.”

Assemblywoman Teresa Sayward said, “I commend the Governor for once again listening to the local residents and taking their thoughts into consideration before making his decision. I am very pleased with his appointments and I am looking forward to working closely with both Lani Ulrich and Sherman Craig on issues that are important to the North Country and those living in the Adirondack Park.”

Brian Houseal, executive director of the Adirondack Council, said, "We congratulate Governor Cuomo on his wise decision to designate Lani Ulrich as Chair of the Adirondack Park Agency and to nominate Sherman Craig to the Board. As a co-founder of the Adirondack Common Ground Alliance, Lani has demonstrated the leadership skills needed for the Park today, as we seek solutions that will benefit the Park's communities and the economy, while also protecting its environment. Sherman Craig also brings balance to the APA, with experience in both economic development and environmental stewardship."

Brian Towers, Supervisor Town of Wells and President of the Adirondack Association of Towns and Villages (AATV) said, “The AATV applauds Governor Cuomo for his excellent selection for APA Chair. As a sitting in-park Commissioner, Lani Ulrich embraces the principle that land preservation and open space must be balanced with the need for growth and employment opportunities for the people who call the Adirondack Park their home. Governor Cuomo should be commended for working with the AATV to make recommendations to the APA board, a practice former Governor Mario Cuomo began and he has chosen to continue. The AATV screened several candidates this year for commissioner and are also pleased with the Governor’s selection of Sherman Craig from the Town of Wanakena, St. Lawrence County. Sherman’s experience as a local businessman whose furniture business utilizes local resources is exactly the type of perspective needed on the APA board. These appointments are another example of Governor Cuomo’s commitment to working with Local Governments throughout the Park and we are looking forward to working with the new Chair and Commissioner.”

Tony Collins, President of Clarkson University and Co-chair of the Governor’s North Country Regional Economic Development Council said, “Leilani Ulrich and Sherman Craig have proven records of partnering with diverse stakeholders to advance sustainable development in the Adirondack Park. They will be key allies in our efforts to strengthen the economy in the North Country.”

Neil Woodworth, Executive Director of the Adirondack Mountain Club said, "The Adirondack Mountain Club (ADK) welcomes the appointment of Leilani Ulrich as chair of the Adirondack Park Agency. ADK has worked with Lani Ulrich as part of the Adirondack Common Ground Alliance, where she strove for a balance between protection of the unique and precious environment of the Adirondacks and sustainable economic development for its citizens and communities. ADK also strongly endorses the appointment of Sherman Craig as a member of the Agency Board. Through his innovative leadership in creating the Cranberry 50 trail and Little River canoe/kayak access projects, Sherman has demonstrated that public use of the Forest Preserve can promote sustainable tourism and economic development for Adirondack communities.”

The Adirondack Park Agency Board consists of 11 members. By statue, the Commissioner of the Department of Economic Development, the Commissioner of the Department of Environmental Conservation and the Secretary of State are all members. The 8 other members are nominated by the Governor and confirmed by the Senate. Of those 8, five members must reside full-time in the Park and three must reside full-time outside the Park. No more than 5 of the eight may be of the same political party.

The Adirondack Park Agency (APA) was created in 1971 by the New York State Legislature to develop long-range land use plans for both public and private lands within the boundary of the Park. The APA is a New York State governmental agency with an eleven-member board. The Agency Board meets monthly to act on Park policy issues and permit applications. Agency Board meetings take place the second Thursday and Friday of each month and are open to the public.

Appearing a short time ago on the public radio program Capital Pressroom, Governor Andrew Cuomo said he was preparing to name a new chair for the Adirondack Park Agency.

"Yes, we did a series of interviews," Cuomo said.  "We'll have an announcement imminent on the APA.  Hold fast, it will be imminent.  Now how we define imminent is very, very, very soon."

Sources tell NCPR that Governor Cuomo is set to name Leilani "Lani" Ulrich as the new chair of the Adirondack Park Agency.

The governor's office hasn't yet confirmed the reports.  Efforts to reach Ulrich this morning were unsuccessful.

NCPR will be following this story through the day and will have updates during All Before Five.

APA, Governor Cuomo go down to the wire on Big Tupper resort

October 11th, 2011 by Brian Mann

This week, the Adirondack Park Agency commission is scheduled to take its first big plunge into the truly, final last deliberations that will shape a vote on the Adirondack Club and Resort project in Tupper Lake.

On Friday, the entire Agency board and the executive team staff from the APA will tour the site, under the supervision of administrative law judge Daniel O'Connell.

The wrinkle, of course, is that the board sets off on this journey without a chairperson.

Curt Stiles stepped aside over the summer and so far, Governor Andrew Cuomo hasn't picked a replacement — either an interim or a permanent chair.

(Press attention has fallen on commissioner Lani Ulrich as a possible new leader for the agency, but the governor's office has stayed mum.)

The process continues to rumble forward, but it's hard to imagine the board navigating this decision — this is one of the biggest, most controversial decisions in the history of the APA — without stable leadership.

In past interviews, all sides of this debate have told me that they think it would be very disruptive to have a leadership change, or new appointment, made in the middle of active deliberations, which will continue from this week into the winter.

I have a call in to the governor's office to see if there are any new developments, and it may be that some kind of announcement will come ahead of the APA meeting.

I will also say that sources at the Agency have told me that they think the executive staff and long-time commission members are handling this uncertainty well.

But this is a process that will face intense public scrutiny, and likely a legal challenge as well.

In the past decade, APA chairmen like Dick LeFebvre, Ross Whaley and Curt Stiles really shaped big decisions like this, and served a key role in handling public perception, as well as communications with Albany.

So…this is uncharted territory.  Look for updates as the week goes along.